Biberach: a heating plant twice the size it needed
that a proven CHP design would have saved, according to the state audit office.[2]
Around €1.8 million over a 20-year plant life (our estimate, undiscounted).
The Baden-Württemberg police college got an innovative energy centre at its site in Biberach, Germany, in 2015 for €2.4 million: CHP, a heat pump, an electric instantaneous heater, solar thermal and heat storage, designed to sell flexibility to the power grid. The external consultant had advised against the concept as economically inadvisable.[2]
The Baden-Württemberg audit office later found that the electricity trader's fee had been based on inflated heat-consumption figures: actual heat use came in more than 500 MWh lower every year. The CHP units ran only 2,200 full-load hours a year, under 25% utilisation. The instantaneous heater and solar thermal had no effect at all, and the heating centre was 100% oversized.[2, 3]